What are my rights if the court lost my DUI file?
My case was transferred from one city to another, and the court lost my file what are my rights? Can I have my DUI dismissed because of this error?


Answered by: Attorney Peter GoldscheiderCall Me: (650) 323-8296
Answered on: 2/25/2012 - This answer applies to: California
Not unless they are unable to bring you to trial within the statutory time or otherwise by the absence of the file deprive you of a separate fundamental right (i.e. loss of evidence etc.).

Answered by: Attorney Patrick J. McDonnellCall Me: (716) 565-2100
Answered on: 2/24/2012 - This answer applies to: New York
If they lost your file what do they have to make a case against you.
Answered by: Attorney Cynthia HenleyCall Me: (713) 222-1220
Answered on: 2/24/2012 - This answer applies to: Texas
Your case could not have been transferred. Perhaps your probation was transferred. You have not provided information that would require a dismissal.

Answered by: Attorney Michael BreczinskiCall Me: (810) 743-2960
Answered on: 2/23/2012 - This answer applies to: Michigan
This might give your attorney some bargaining power but probably not a dismissal.

Answered by: Attorney Jared AltmanCall Me: (914) 737-0200
Answered on: 2/23/2012 - This answer applies to: New York
No. It won't be dismissed. The file will get re-created.

Answered by: Attorney John CarneyCall Me: (917) 696-2363
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: New York
I have not heard of a court losing a file before. The prosecutor should have a copy of the information and the supporting deposition. If not they should be able to print another copy. The court may allow them to simply prepare new documents. You should ask your attorney as he is more familiar with the case.

Answered by: Attorney Steve FreebornCall Me:
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Washington
If the court lost your file and the prosecutor cannot prove its case, then you will in all likelihood get a dismissal.

Answered by: Attorney Timothy J. ThillCall Me: (708) 443-1200
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Illinois
If there is no file, there is no record of the case, however, the court clerk can reconstruct a file, and it would be a decision of the prosecutor and/or the judge to determine if the case file, as reconstructed, is sufficient to proceed against you.

Answered by: Attorney John CommonsCall Me: (317) 253-3110
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Indiana
I expect it is possible for them to reconstruct the file. If you don't already have a lawyer, you should hire one.

Answered by: Attorney Mark ThiessenCall Me: (713) 428-2322
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Texas
No, it's not an automatic dismissal, but hire a great DWI attorney and sounds like lots of room for error.

Answered by: Attorney Jeff YehCall Me: (213) 446-2495
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: California
Possibly. Hire a DUI specialist so you don't get fooled by them. Chances are there can be sanctions imposed, but as long as the prosecutor has their file there are thingsfor which to continue the prosecution.
Answered by: Attorney Craig AndersenCall Me: (360) 397-0111
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Washington
IF they can't find it and two years go by, the case will be dismissed because the Statute of Limitations (SOL) will have run. Note that it runs from the date of the dismissal of the case in the first court. Make sure that the new court, the Department of Licensing and the police have your correct address so they can't claim you fled the state. That would "toll" the SOL. Also, if the court can't recreate your file from audio tapes or copies, make a motion to dismiss for failure to preserve a record. Other than that, I'd lay low and let the time pass.

Answered by: Attorney Richard WilliamsCall Me: (251) 272-3765
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Alabama
I would be surprised if the file does not eventually show up. Until then, I would leave it alone!

Answered by: Attorney Thomas J. TomkoCall Me: (586) 795-8822
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Michigan
In this situation, I believe that a Motion To Dismiss could be filed. You should hire an attorney to get this done so that you are not railroaded into admissions. Also, do not provide the Court with copies of any documents you may have, like a breathalyzer test result or statement, etc. Contact this office with questions or if you wish to hire this office to seek the dismissal.

Answered by: Attorney Craig ElhartCall Me: (231) 946-2420
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Michigan
The loss of the file probably will not result in a dismissal of the charges as the documents in the file can be recreated.

Answered by: Attorney Phillip L. WeiserCall Me: (316) 260-7070
Answered on: 2/22/2012 - This answer applies to: Kansas
The answer depends upon what was lost. If the City does not have sufficient evidence to proceed, then they will most likely have to dismiss the case.